Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 08 August 2008

Costello ignored inflation warnings: Swan

5/05/2008 8:40:00 PM.  | 
Labor has seized on documents suggesting Peter Costello ignored Treasury advice about the threat posed by inflation and a rapid rise in government spending.

Documents obtained under freedom of information laws show the former treasurer and other senior Howard government ministers were warned about the impact of rising inflation six months before last year's federal budget.

The Treasury minutes obtained by the Nine Network show Mr Costello was warned the economy was running close to capacity and that there was a real risk significant spending would add to inflationary pressures.

Treasurer Wayne Swan was quick to point to the documents as proof that the Howard government is largely to blame for the inflation problem and higher interest rates.

Labor has committed tocutting spending as part of its so-called inflation fighting budget.

COMMENTS

Monday, 05 May 2008

Swan should release the complete document. He is being selective about the detail he is releasing. Live News - can you access the full text of the Treasury document referred to?

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Monday, 05 May 2008

Damn right, lets get the full story. Or is it?

Posted by: Bart R, Sydney

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Bolts, this is another typical "blame the previous govt" campaign that is designed to be the excuse for Swan to issue a "tightening the belt" budget. Rudd & Co obviously knew that inflationary pressure existed BEFORE the election & they said that they have "fresh ideas" & "new leadership" to "put downward pressure to inflation",etc. Whether Costello was warned is irrelevant, as now they have absolutely no idea how to tackle the issue so they have to resort to this blaming game. Not a surprise.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

WO & Mr Bolton,Bart:"Whether Costello was warned is irrelevant" What a stupid statement,Costello ignored Warnings,Failed to act and subsequently stuffed up our economy.AND you defend him?Yes bring out all the documents so we can see the truth.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Paul, obviously you are quick to defend your master. I repeat - whether Costello was warned or not is irrelevant! The most important thing is whether the stupid & clueless Swan is going to do about it! I didn't defend Costello in my comments - whether Costello acted or not is open to debate & is a topic for another day. Giving Swan has the ability to take comments out of context & without seeing document in its entirety one will have to think this is a tactic to distract from Swan's incompetence

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Paul, one more point - "stuffing up the economy" huh? What a stupid statement! Inflation is a by-product of good economy & also the unemployment is record low. Obviously labor's trademark is to send the economy into recession (which your worshipped hero was very capable of doing). "Interest rate will always be higher under labor". "Working families had never been better off". In hindsight these statements were dead true. Things have been going downhill for working families since Nov last year.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

WO, 'Whether Costello acted or not is a topic for another day'...Mate, this IS THE TOPIC OF THIS FORUM! Why wont you make a comment on the topic rather that make another one? I would like to hear what you have to say in regards to Costello and his alledged ignoring of inflation figures.

Posted by: David ., NSW

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

David, my point is without seeing the document in its entirety and the context the statement was included (if at all!)in the document one cannot debate it either way. Obviously you take my statement out of the context and are willing to accept whatever Swan has fed you via the media.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Keating, if you want to see "stuffing up the economy" just watch Rudd & Swan over the next 12 months (if the first 6 is anything to go by). Rudd will need to say "sorry" to the mugs that elected him. Stevens (RBA) says inflation is higher than desired but under control. He doesn't mention "disaster" "genie" etc etc etc.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

David.Very good comment,W.O. Stick with the topic and do you defend Costello if allegations are true? Awaiting your reply.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Paul, no point discussing about something IF it is true....I have my views about Costello and can speculate what he would have done instead of the useless Swan. But it is MY view and I am not Costello. Prove it to me that the statement is true then we can debate. No point debating on something when its validity is in question, unless you are a labor supporter who has no logic.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Paul, one more point - Rudd & Co knew BEFORE the election that there might be an inflationary issue and they said that they have "fresh ideas" on how to put "downward pressure" on inlfation. What have they done so far? 6 months not long enough? How long do you need? If after 6 months all Rudd & Co can come up with is blaming Costello for his allegely inaction, it is then a very PATHETIC performance!

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Bolton: This Forum is debating about Costello.If you wish to defend your Hero please do so.But stick with the Topic.I know it's hard but you can do it?

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Paul Recession Keating- Labor cannot afford to criticise the Coalitions spending because they copied the daddy of them all-the $34 billion tax cuts. It just goes to prove that in their grab for power they were prepared to ignore the very same things that they are accusing the Coalition of doing. Very mercenary.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Looks live this Topic (Costello) has hit a very sensitive nerve in the Liberal supporters.Their Hero's reputation has been tarnished.I have an idea that he ignored the warnings because he knew Labor was going to win Election so he Sabotaged our economy out of Spite.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Paul, inflation is not necessarily a bad thing especially when it comes with a booming economy. Check this fact by studying economic 101. Your master Keating gave us high inflation even in recession, and now it seems Rudd is heading in the same direction if he is not careful. What Costello did or could have done is irrelevant, as Rudd & Swan claimed they had all the answers BEFORE the election and obviously that's a vote gathering big lie from the hindsight.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 

Monday, 05 May 2008

Let's say Peter Costello was a very capable Treasurer, and he seemed to know how to handle the rough stuff as well as the good easy stuff, and he also managed to share some of the Gov profits with the pensioners and the like. I'm afraid if Peter was in the harness right now, things wouldn't be in the state they are. cheers LK.

Posted by: Lawrie Kilgour, Sunshine Coast

 

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

I want to see the documents - there is no point making a statement and not showing this to the public - where's our right to know!

Posted by: Red Square ****, sydney

 

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Regardless of who is to "blame" what is Wayne Swan going to do about it? One would think that on a day such as this the focus would be more on the soon to be released budget. Perhaps it just clever politics but what we actually need is a clever government.

Posted by: Dennis Cole, Newtown

 

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

The Nine Network eh? Who could forget the one eyed worm that they engineered before the last election. They have no credibility as political commentators. Labor has no credibility when it comes to managing the economy because one must cut through the politics and be guided by the actual records of the two major parties. The previous Labor Governments performance with Coalition figures in brackets-Debt left $96 billion (surplus), average home mortgage rate 12.75%(7.2%), Unemployment 8.2% (4.2%), Inflation 5.2% (2.5%), Real wake growth minus 1.8.(19.8%).The Coalition kept inflation down in a booming economy so Labor should be able to do the same.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Des, obviously facts & figures don't lie unless one is a misguided labor supporter! Given Coalition's performance there are still labor supporters who claim that lib stuffed up the economy. What a joke. At least we have higher inflation with a booming economy - labor gave us high inflation even in recession in early 90s! I often thought that economically speaking, it takes a particularly stupid group of people to generate high inflation, high unemployment and high interest rate at the same time!

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Des, Its a real short memory you have. When Howard was 'boy treasurer' in the Fraser government the economy and industry resembled the museum of antiquities.What was Howard's unemployment figures during the Fraser years, what was inflation and GDP? What of Howard and Costello's recent 'foreign debt'? What short memories you all have. Des, as for the worm, I would liked to have seen 'ol man Howard' hooked up to polygraph. If it was not for the reforms made by Keating we would still be living in a conservative penal colony isolated from the rest of the world!

Posted by: Sean Ambrose, Helensburgh

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Ambrose...Howard AND Rudd hooked up to polygraphs would be interesting! Please don't try and convince us that Rudd hasn't/doesn't tell porkies? Forget your ideology for one moment and be real....all pollies are liars! OK? ("....hmmm I have no recollection of what I did in that strip club" Rudd would have been mnore believable if he'd said, "Yep, went there, did some perving, bit of hands on, had a great time!" Rudd is NOT squeaky clean.. he is ofetn very sparing with the truth, as I said a liar)

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Sean Ambrose Helensburg-You said it Howard was Treasurer and not the PM. Look at Fraser now he behaves like a Labor man-any way if you want to go back to that you must also include the disgraceful Whitlam years-shocking stuff. I don't think that Rudd would make a very pretty sight strapped up to a PolyGram-he would just keep mumbling-I can't remember I drank too much. Keating was an absolute flop and we have a recession to prove it. His deregulation of the Banks is what is hurting 'working families’ to day

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Labor spin again. Keeps true believers happy.

Posted by: james stack,

 

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Ridiculous. Costello dealt with inflation as well as was humanly possible. Sadly the ALP have abrogated the fight. In fact, packages such as workchoices were rather effective. The proof can be seen with the skyrocketing inflation once the ALP took over.

Posted by: Indie Fatigue ah Ball, Carramar/Sydney

 

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Since 2004 our Imports have outstripped our Exports! The gap is getting bigger.This is not good for our Economy and Inflation.For a truly strong economy we need to Export more.What would happen if there was a downturn in Minerals? Disaster.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Paul, seems that you have a rather short memory (or want to stir up discussion?). We have visited this before. The increase import is partly due to the floating of A$ which your labor pals introduced. Nothing wrong with the resource boom - China wants it, we sell it. What's the problem-I bet you will say anything negative under the sun is lib's fault. Also import goods actually REDUCES inflation as overseas wages are a lot LOWER than Australians' (again thanks to you labor pal pushing up wages)

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

W.O, Imported products reduce our living standards, wages and skills base, the last government did nothing to address the skills crisis except for introduce its wretched 457 visas. As for 'competing' with China, we should be raising their standards of living not reducing ours!

Posted by: Sean Ambrose, Helensburgh

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Ambrose, you really need to move forward. We used to grow sheep and make things because (1) labour was cheap and (2) tariffs protected us. Our marketable skills today are not in manufacturing (because our labor costs are too high), but we enjoy leadership in high value adding non-manufacturing areas. Using your theory, we should still manufacture all our clothing here in Australia? Dumb. You couldn't afford it, and what's more YOU wouldn't want to work in that industry. Move on dinosaur!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Sean, picture this: In the supermarket two pieces of houseware with identical function. The first one is made in China which costs say $5 & the second is made in Australia which costs $12. Which one will you purchase? Don't be a hypocrite & say you will purchase Australian made. My point is the world economy is a free market, & we now need to compete globally. If you can't compete you are out of the door. You can stay at your ideology all you want while the rest of us moves on.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

WO: You hit the nail right on the head. We need too compete globally,How do we do it? We can't compete with labour Costs so we need to compete with technology and Skills.Hang on haven't i heard that from someone else? Thats right it was Kevin Rudd.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

Paul, my comments are in relation to Sean's statement that import reduces our living standard. That is not true. If anything it actually increases our living standard as we can purchase cheaper goods. As for competitiveness, yes I don't think we should compete on labor but has Rudd actually DONE (not talk - I have heard him talking too much) or is planning to do anyhing about it? Giving schools PCs? What industries does he think Australia can compete on? Haven't heard his comment on this at all.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

To the Lib supporters complaining about how the economy has performed in the past 6 months, here is a simple fact. This is Swann's first budget.The economy of the past 6 months is the result of all the previous budgets, that is, Costello's. Costello turned the tap on and the bucket overflowed. Swann is now walking in the mud where the bucket overflowed and the Lib supporters say, "Look at all the all the mud that Swann has made".

Posted by: k m, south perth

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

KM, so be definition you are saying that Rudd's lads have done nothing till now to fix the problem (as they see it?). Good to know that you still credit Howard with the low unemployment!

Posted by: Gazza Benson, Blacktown

Wednesday, 07 May 2008

KM from south perth: using your own words-Rudd & Co knew BEFORE election that they will be in "mud in the bucket" (which I disagree as I don't think the current economic situation is in a mud but that's a different issue) and they said that they have "fresh ideas" to "put downward pressure on inflation". What we have seen so far over the last 6 months is nothing but ideological gestures (saying sorry, signing Kyoto, watching whales, overseas photo trips, bashing banks). They are a clueless bunch

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Wednesday, 07 May 2008