Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Wednesday, 07 January 2009

Banned drug booklet could have saved lives

19/06/2008 8:29:00 AM.  | Alan Jones

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

Look, the drugs pamphlet has occupied a lot of attention in the last 48 hours.

Reba Meagher has called the document offensive and has ordered it to be pulped. The Acting Education Minister John Hatzistergos described it as unsuitable. And questions are being asked how the document could have been produced by the Sydney West Area Health Service in the first place.

Now it's also sponsored by New South Wales Health, and there's an association with the Panthers Rugby League football club. Questions are being asked as to how many of these pamphlets were produced and how much it cost taxpayers.

Where the critics are right - and I was one of them - is on the issue of the mixed message.

Now I hate drugs and I think there's only one way they should be approached: total abstinence - or the clichéd zero tolerance.

That said, it is important to recognise that the document does contain some worthy material.

It says, adjacent to a diagram of the brain: "Here's a few important things you should know" and it does tell you that people with a family history of mental illness are at high risk if they take drugs. That cannabis may unlock a psychosis, especially in young people. That young people who begin using drugs regularly at an early age are at a higher risk of mental health problems. That mixing drugs puts people at more risk of harm.

It stresses the mental health consequences. And then the mixed message which then says, "A few tips".

But to be fair, it does say "The best way to keep your head together is not to use drugs at all".

But then it says "If you choose to experiment, get to know your family medical history" and then this, "Let your brain finish most of its development before experimenting" - in other words, that's a pitch to kids to leave them alone. And then it says "Use only small amounts and not too often".

Now you could argue that in an ideal world everyone will be off drugs. But if we're not going to win that battle in the short term - we'll continue the fight in the long term - some of those so-called tips just might help to save a life.

The brochure then provides a whole range of contacts for anyone who might have a mental health problem, or might be using drugs.

In short, it could have been done better, some of the language is loose. But it's not without merit, even though it's not perfect.

But then the drug issue doesn't admit of perfect solutions either.

To be fair, it does say "The best way to keep your head together is not to use drugs at all." It's not too much to hope that one day that message will be understood by everybody.

One final point.

Where does alcohol fit into this?

It's a drug.

And legal.

COMMENTS

Thursday, 19 June 2008

The book is a very clever stunt by the Government in marketing. They used the reverse sell deliberately knowing the outrage and condemnation it rightly deserved as a bombastically proposterous suposition kids apparently would be encouraged for one minute to take drugs? What were they thinking? Quickie mart edits the newspapers and media Homer Simpson style? I have one comment for Western Area Health Service? DOH!

Posted by: Phillip Caine, Hawkesbury

 

Thursday, 19 June 2008

Alan is in agreement with the publication's advice, for the introduction to drugs of addiction - 'use small amounts and not too often'. So the young are faced with a choice - total abstinance, or it's ok to use small amounts. I hope he doesn't come into contact with any young people.

Posted by: Thomas Catt, Canberra

 

Thursday, 19 June 2008

Thousands of hours of research go into this leaflet, surveys of youth opinion, case examples, psychological testing, in order to find the appropriate wording to get the kids off drugs. Does anyone really think that something like this would be released without due diligence? Now its banned 'cause the media has shown it in the wrong light. And we wonder why as a society we keep going round in circles.

Posted by: andrew ., Sydney

Thursday, 19 June 2008

Andrew, take comfort in the knowledge that this couldn't happen in China or any country owned by a dictator.

Posted by: Thomas Catt, Canberra

 

Thursday, 19 June 2008

Thousand of taxpayers money was misued-it's nothing but fraud. Did they produce the booklet for nothing? Thousands of hours go into this leaflet?. Sounds like youth opinion and case studies failed!!A duty of care applies to every child in this country and not in an ad hoc fashion-this is nothing but bureaucratic propaganda gone wrong and absolutely useless, how many trees were used to produce this rubbish? It's obvious whoever approved this needs to be made accountable for it-nothing is mentioned on this issue and yet the booklet was immediately removed by the nobel Reba Meagher and a useless comment made by the caretaker Minister for Education. And we ask why there are so many mental and behaviour issues? It should have been designed a lot better than it had been - how many psychologists or psychiatrists were involved in this - due diligence? more like incompetence and who are these so called experts who actually screw up so many kids and adults anyhow by misdiagnosis or the provision

Posted by: Dan Concerned, *

Thursday, 19 June 2008

continued: provision of prescription drugs.It's called keeping the pharmaceutical companies rich! Cigarettes and drinking should also be included. Alan, if you agree that this was a good attempt, it's obvious you too are missing the plot but then you are paid so I guess that's your excuse. Thomas you make a very good point.

Posted by: Dan Concerned, *

 

Thursday, 19 June 2008

at the end of the day though people like myself dont need to be told how to use drugs as we are working things out for ourselves and communicating to each other on sites like erowid. drug trends have reflected this info to some degree. in my own circles drugs of addiction are scorned. cannabis is in a grey area as it can leave you foggy but used once in a while its harmless. psychedelics though = great fun, no addiction, no problems the next day if you use them in the right set and setting.

Posted by: David Kure, Adelaide

 

Thursday, 19 June 2008

So Alan are you now saying that you are an advocate of harm minimisation? This is a seismic shift -didn't think that I would live to see the day. You talk about the possibility of this booklet saving lives but it could also take a lot of lives by giving the wrong message to impressionable young people. As we know young people like to grow up before their time-they will look at the bit that says 'wait till you are 18'- it will be like a red rag to a bull-the old forbidden fruit syndrome.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Friday, 20 June 2008

This might sound naive but am I the only one that sees a problem with Government funded literature, released to students in a government school, with content that entertains ILLEGAL activity by minors? The bottom line is that so far, in our society illicit drug use has been deemed to be illegal and, until that changes, kids should not be even given the OPTION of feeling that it's ok to use drugs. If things like that are to be said to kids, it should be their parents that do it not beaurocrats.

Posted by: Jo Stalin, Sydney

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
LiveNews now available on mobile devices

YOUR SAY

Muslims protesting at the Airport would cause absolute chaos. Better leave it in Macquarie St. after all.... online sudonym, on Islamic rally causes traffic dramas in Sydney's CBD

Keely Smith I hear you. Like you I live and work in the local area and am absolutely sick and tired of the crap... Lisa G, Campbelltown area on Alleged Rosemeadow brawler walks free from court

Never let the facts get in the way of a good story.... The dogs involved have been identified as mixed breed dogs - yet you post... Tracie McIntosh, Springhurst on Three-year-old mauled to death - toddler, adult hospitalised

Far out, medical help was all developed in Israel. Quick get em on to Cancer. What has this got to do with an... online sudonym, on Islamic rally causes traffic dramas in Sydney's CBD

Jones wouldn't know a game of rugby if he fell over it. Shut up Eddie, no one wants to listen to you bleat!... Shut up Eddie, Sydney on Jones slams ELVs after Saracens loss