Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 29 August 2008

Our petrol tax cut is different to theirs: Swan

20/07/2008 10:02:00 AM.  | 
Labor's plan to spare motorists from rising fuel costs under emissions trading is very different to the opposition's petrol policy, Treasurer Wayne Swan says.

Under the government plan, transport will be included in the roll-out of a national emissions trading scheme (ETS), but petrol excise will be cut to compensate for any ETS-related price rise cent-for-cent.

The excise will be cut for three years and then the policy will be reviewed.

Federal opposition leader Brendan Nelson proposed cutting the excise by five cents a litre in his budget reply speech earlier this year.

"They attacked us bitterly for proposing it, now they have half adopted it for a sufficient period of time to get them through an election," opposition environment spokesman Greg Hunt said last week.

But today Mr Swan said the plan was very different to the coalition's policy to cut the fuel excise by five cents a litre.

"There's a huge difference between the position that we are putting in the (climate change) green paper and what Brendan Nelson said in his budget reply," Mr Swan told the Ten Network.

"We have got a long-term economic reform here which is terribly important, he (Nelson) had an un-costed, unfunded thought bubble."

COMMENTS

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Talking about "uncosted", "unfunded thought bubble"! What a joke labor is accusing others things they have done themselves. Examples of "uncosted", "unfunded" policies - "education revolution", "increase medicare threshhold", "mean testing baby bonus" which will cost more to administer than the saving! Swan has either no shame and/or no logic. It's no wonder Australia is in such an economic turnmoil unde the leadership of this goose.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Sunday, 20 July 2008

If Swan is implying that all policies have to costed before being discussed he has to explain why his Party’s main policy platforms, at the last election, were not costed. Global warming-no costing or time table provided and Industrial Relations-no economic modeling as to what the changes would do for jobs, International competition, and taxes and benefits.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Des, as Andrew Bolt said on "The Insiders" today, Rudd won the election with absolutely no policies.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Geoff, it's ok, Rudder is working the public service overtime to try to put something together; anyway he can always adapt more of John Howards plans.

Posted by: Shawn Lamb, Canberra

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Geoff, he didn't need policies, the tru believers are always there, the under 30's and immigrants who arrived since 1995 have never known a recession or high interest and inflation. All he needed was a few promises to make food, petrol and home interest rates cheaper and a smooth hair style; and a few sympathetic young journalists.

Posted by: Rob Banks, Canberra

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Rob... "a FEW sympathetic journalists!" surely you mean " a few PATHETIC journalists!". Our media is PATHETIC (with a few exceptions...Piers Akerman, Andrew Bolt, Laurie Oaks etc)

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Yeah! Some so catastrophic to the Australian economy; something so costly to the Australian taxpayer with zero benefit; and something which is backed by no hard science as warming stopped 12 years ago; and it's released during WYD week. Well done the Labor Party! Swan describes the Liberal Policy as a "thought bubble". Well, where's all your policy with the alternatives to actually reduce any so-called polluting carbon; LPG, CNG, wave, solar, nuclear etc? This is just a focus on yet another tax.

Posted by: David Ready, Padstow

 

Sunday, 20 July 2008

My Goodness when are the Australian public going to wake and realise what these morons are doing to the Australian economy. This is a steam roller at the top of the hill with no breaks, and Rudd is the driver, and Swan and Wong are the little people with the red flag, walking in front. While the rest of Asia looks on in disbelief.

Posted by: Andy Mac, HK

 

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Swan - you are the ultimate fool. Go away.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Sunday, 20 July 2008

I can feel that funny feeling I once had, many years ago when ...Keating was in power. Does any one else feel it? Surely some of you remember the feeling of a Budget Black Hole approaching? i worry at the size of this one as our GOVT's have been selling us off at break neck speed. Fuel excise cut? How about you kill the Parity pricing of the Singapore Index? Cuppla years and we get some common sense back in power!

Posted by: nick Again, Maryborough

 

Monday, 21 July 2008

In reply to Nick Again from Maryborough - Yes mate, I can feel that same old Labor feeling you've been talking about. When are people going to open their eyes and realise that, as they look back over many many years, it just so happens that all the Labor years are the "bad" years, for business, for families, for workers, for just about every6one except the Unions that seem to pop up and thrive when Labor get in. And by coincidence, the Lib held years seem to be the opposite - funny about that.

Posted by: Jo Stalin, Sydney

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 

YOUR SAY

Do the school know if australia is an island or a continent? At school they told us 1 or the other. Different answers from different... clayden vidler, gympie on Rudd in need of a geography lesson

This is no surprise if it were any ordinary citizen you would have been stripped of all your rights, paid a huge fine and... Dan Concerned, * on Pat O'Shane escapes drink driving conviction

We faced a lot of difficult economic times, domestically and internationally, under the Coalition but never did we see such low levels of Business and... Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill on Rudd in need of a geography lesson

Nick Again:I respect what you have to say however this article is about sedatives given to the elderly in these so called nursing homes (nothing... Dan Concerned, * on Nursing homes 'too reliant on sedatives'

Concerned Liberal, Minto, That was dishonest. Pithy, The Aus Liberals are to the right of the Third Reich, The moved to the extreme right under... Graeme Henderson, Darling Downs on Australian citizenship test to be radically overhauled