Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 05 December 2008

Greer: Reconciliation is a joke

22/08/2008 11:01:00 PM.  | AAP
Reconciliation between white and indigenous people in Australia is a bitter joke, feminist Germaine Greer said tonight.

Ms Greer, speaking to about 2,000 people at the Melbourne Writers' Festival at the Melbourne Town Hall, said indigenous Australians had never accepted the apology by Prime Minister Kevin Rudd for the stolen generation.

"Saying sorry was something (Mr Rudd) needed to say, but he didn't quite say sorry for the right things," Ms Greer said.

"He said sorry to the stolen generation, but he didn't say sorry to the huge disruption that gave birth to the stolen generation.

"Reconciliation is a bitter joke which nobody is laughing at."

She said while an important thing about the apology was to make Australians feel better, even more important was that Aboriginal people were seen to accept it.

"But they didn't, and nobody asked them," Ms Greer said.

"It is not enough to say sorry - we haven't got to first base in saying sorry, yet."

She said a treaty had to be set up with indigenous Australians and it had to be conducted with respect and dignity.

"Man to man, equal person to equal person," she said.

"We have to make ourselves listen, instead of forever telling Aboriginal people what is in their best interests."

She said white Australia had destroyed Aborigines' languages and their English skills were lacking because "we educated them so badly".

She said the treaty had to be established at a political level and politicians may have to sit with Aborigines for weeks before learning what they want.

"If we go to listen to them we will have to be patient, because it won't come all at once. It may take weeks before people begin to speak to us and the words they say we won't like," Ms Greer said.

"The words they say won't make us feel good. They won't be words that congratulate us."

COMMENTS

Friday, 22 August 2008

Germ hasn't lived here for a lot of years, would someone please tell the poor old Greer to get relevant....( shaking head at the media that still thinks that she is worthy of space )

Posted by: keith rowland, tweed heads

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

I agree that the apology did not include everything. They should also say sorry for genocide during invasion. Apologize also for taking away dreamtime tradition.

Posted by: james small, bankstown

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

dreamtime tradition, dot painting and several dances only became reality after 1956......funny that...!!!

Posted by: keith rowland, tweed heads

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

OMG, she is back. This must be pushing her book sales through the roof. Funny she always wants to come back to Australia just long enough to promote something she has written, or to bestow some of her wisdom (in her own mind) on us lowly peasents. Shame the media never releases the views she spouts overseas on how much she hates Australia and Australians. Mundine and Pearson would run rings around her. Go away Greer, pleeeeeeeeease !!!

Posted by: susan lowe, gippsland

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

Anyone notice the blatant hypocricy? First Greer brow-beats everyone for constantly telling the aboriginals what is good for them and being basically paternalistic but then concludes by saying that "we did not teach them English well enought etc. etc." like she was talking about children. I have never understood why anyone ever cares what this femi-nazi has to say. She has an ego the size of Ullaru.

Posted by: Jo Stalin, Sydney

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

Strange NO mention is made of the "CHURCHES" roles in ALL this harm we did. One wonders what the "plight" of the Aboriginal would have been without the European standing foot in the Country? Would they have been Genocided by the Indonesians'? Perhaps Greer would consider living in an OUTBACH community/mission to see just how much SHE doesn't know? We didnt remove their Language? YOu cant "remove" someones Language! Languauge has gone because the YOUTH weren't interested.

Posted by: Nick Again, Herenthere

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

Oh so true Nick.Language cannot be taken if the youth keep practicing it. Before I get the 'stolen gen' tossed at me as the reason, they werent the only ones who had their children taken from them.'White' unmarried girls did too, I was one of them, Im still waiting for my apology, and unless you have had personal experience in the removal of young unmarried Mothers babies back then, please dont debate this with me.Greer has no experience in anything, other than trying to attract media attention.

Posted by: susan lowe, gippsland

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

So MS. Greer, reconciliation is "a bitter joke"? According to you. The same could be said of you, with emphasis on the bitter. I believe most thinking aboriginal people feel it's about time to look to the future instead of the past.Sorry is what comes from the heart, not forced out of the mouth, and if the word isn't enough then some are too hung up by the past. Mr Mundine and Mr Pearson should be listened to, not a frustrated old crone who never lets nice words pass her lips. Get a life lady.

Posted by: colleen a, Sydney

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

It is always disappointing when someone lauds such a fool as Greer. I won't forgive her racism, in claiming that Aborigines are incapable of altruism, nobility or basic governance. She always takes a left leaning argument and draws it further to the left. It is about time she left for good.

Posted by: Happy Fun Ball, Carramar/Sydney

Saturday, 23 August 2008

I agree with the comment about her. The aborigines the were able to look after themselves ok for about 40,000 years. It wasn't until they were forced into another culture that they have trouble adapting. Many aboriginal people outback have been forced to adapt to a stage within less than approx. 150 years to where the English adapted at their own pace over approx. 4,500 years.

Posted by: Rob Banks, Canberra

 

Saturday, 23 August 2008

Rob , I dont think the likes of Greer would ever have contemplated anything as intelligent as your post. You are absolutely correct, it is a process that will take many more years for our indigenous people in some remote communites. Sadly too many like Greer, want to wallow in their version of past history, without offering anything realistic or constructive, to move forward. People like Pearson and Mundine are tryng to make a future, by moviing forward.

Posted by: susan lowe, gippsland

 

Monday, 25 August 2008

Reconcilliation: Greer is a joke!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Monday, 25 August 2008

I'm tired of all this politically correct waffle, 'invasions' have been happening since time began. The Spartans, Romans, Vikings, Goths, Persians etc have all invaded countries over thousands of years, i don't hear any bleating about apologizes for those various cultures who were overrun. Australia's 'invasion' was a normal part of history at the time, many thousands of indigenous people lost their lives and it was a terrible thing but wringing our hands and saying sorry won't change anything.

Posted by: paul harris, sydney

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
Register to receive daily news and sports details

YOUR SAY

He should be sacked. He should be made an example to the young kids who look up to these players as being perfect. They will... Frank chappell, emu plains on Bird granted stay of execution

Good call Jay K! Ch 10 finds out what it's like to be on the receiving end for a change. Add Smallville to the list... Ross R, Normanhurst on Ten miffed at Thank God You’re Here defection

An independant commision should happen! It appears that the OPI is in essence just another arm of Vicpol ESD. Each "block" of... Adam CARRIGG, Somerville on Corruption in Vic police ranks: Overland

See henderson thats the difference between you and most people. We dont tolerate terrorists where as you support terrorist actions. Your weak gutted approach... Pete 2, North Sydney on EXCLUSIVE: Parliament petrol protester breaks silence

He didn't need a plan of succession, no problem running the business from jail.... Rob Banks, Canberra on Prisoner ran drug ring from jail: police