Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 09 January 2009

Rudd promises to pursue luxury car tax

4/09/2008 9:17:00 PM.  | Richard Maxton
The federal government has vowed to reintroduce legislation for a luxury car tax, after the measure was defeated by the Opposition today.

Labor's plan to increase the tax on cars worth more than $57,000, has been overturned in the Senate by 34 votes to 33. 

Government Leader in the Senate Chris Evans, says Labor hasn't given up on the $550 million budget measure.

"Next week we will reintroduce the bill," Mr Evans said.

"Next week we will attempt again to get the Liberals to become responsible, to say the needs of Australian families are more important than the purchase of luxury cars."

"We ask all Senators to put Australian families first."

Family First's Steve Fielding has voted with the Coalition to stop the tax, claiming it would hurt tourism operators and motorists in rural areas.

Greens Leader Bob Brown, who voted for the measure, says Senator Fielding should have taken more time to push his agenda.

"The sensible thing would have been to allow the second reading to vote to go into the committee stages, where he could have tested, with government, the options he was putting forward for protecting people who may be affected by these tax changes in the tourism industry or remote and rural Australia.

"But he didn't. He used his vote to cut the debate off there."

COMMENTS

Thursday, 04 September 2008

Isn't this what democracy is all about? Bob Brown will vote according to his beliefs as will the other Independent Senator-the one that has a thing about Pokies.Whats the fuss about?.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Thursday, 04 September 2008

Maybe Fielding just does not want to carry on with a lot of crap that Brown maybe prone to. Maybe he's saying to the govt get it right first time. Brown should also be pushing his barrow for lower tax on low fuel consumers and higher taxes on guzzlers rather than bleating about this.

Posted by: G Brandis, Sydney

 

Thursday, 04 September 2008

Labor were given a clear mandate to govern at the last election and the Liberals, who seem to make policies on the fly (depending on the political climate on the day I suspect) seem to see their role as spoilers even if it means wrecking the economy. If there were an election now Labor would be returned in an absolute landslide. How about giving democracy a chance?

Posted by: Joe C, Adelaide

Thursday, 04 September 2008

Joe, yes, a clear mandate to govern, but not open slather to tax us into oblivion. Labor are always a higher taxing option. Get used to the fact that they will have a tough time.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Thursday, 04 September 2008

Never mind Joe all good govts can work around a lack of a Senate majority.Fielding was only elected due to the complex preference system.He has no chance at the next election when he comes up for renewal.We saw how ignorant the Liberals were with unfetterred power and they were thrown out.Voters will take note of all measures blocked by the Senate and take retribution next election.We should sit back calmly and watch the Liberals bury themselves deeper and deeper.

Posted by: Lance Freestone, Cambridge Park

Friday, 05 September 2008

Joe C did you hear that "thud" sound? That was me falling on the floor with laughter at your comments. Even Krudds own staff have made comments about how he constantly makes policy up on the run, yet ignorant ALP luvvies like yourself have the audacity to accuse the libs of the same? What a ridiculous argument to make. If Krudd can't handle the pressure he should do a Iemma and get lost. After all, he's just a populist twit who fawns between camera shots to add to his already monstrous ego.

Posted by: Blampa Blamping, Peoples republic of Krudd

Friday, 05 September 2008

Freestone, a gentle reminder....Rudd was also only successful because of the preference system. Without the Greens he was in trouble. You need to be consistent with your "one eyedness"

Posted by: Gareth Benson, Blacktown

Friday, 05 September 2008

JOE-Idon’t know how old you are but you must have a very short memory. Rudd did not tell the people about his luxury Car Tax or his Alcopop Tax so you cannot say that he had a mandate. John Howard told the people, before the corresponding election that he was going to introduce a GST. He was elected and therefore he had a mandate to bring in the Tax. Guess what Labor voted against it-the Coalition needed the help of the Democrats to get it through the Senate. So please let’s not get too precious.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Thursday, 04 September 2008

If Labor had a clear mandate, they wouldn't need the coalition to get their legislation through. The fact is that this new tax did not get the numbers in the Senate which includes a number of independents and minor party senators. It's not that easy to use taxation to deliver excessive election promises AND a massive surplus as well.

Posted by: A Narchy, The Hills

 

Friday, 05 September 2008

Fielding blocked this as farmers need 4wd, what a joke. I had a look at the 50 4wd for sale new over 75k and surprise, all luxury, not middle of the line base models in it. They may need a 4wd to get around, fair enough, but plenty of family wagons available still under 75k for the cockys to slum it in. Fielding just wants to play games, he is joke, bye to him in a double dissolution soon. Fielding is no loss to representing Victorians as very few vic farmers would require a 4wd to drive to town

Posted by: Russell Jones, Toowomba

Friday, 05 September 2008

Jones, you fool. The figure is $57,000 NOT $75,000. No wonder you don't understand. Typical Ruddite moron! YOU are "the joke" not Fielding.

Posted by: Gareth Benson, Blacktown

Friday, 05 September 2008

Thanks benson for pointing out my mistake. I have reposted with readjusted figures but have not readjusted my opinion which you no doubt will be pleased with. I hope that this slip-up of mine does not enhance your opinion of my standing in this forum and you will still and always see me as a 'Ruddite moron'(sic). (nothing could ever make me change my opinion of you benson, just as an aside. That I haven't capitalized your name should give you a small clue as too what that opinion may be.)

Posted by: Russell Jones, Toowomba

 

Friday, 05 September 2008

Fielding blocked this as farmers need 4wd what a joke. I had a look at the 100 4wd for sale new over 57k and surprise, all luxury, not middle of the line base models in it. They may need a 4wd to get around, fair enough, but plenty of family wagons available still under 57k for the cockys to slum it in. BENSON just wants to play games, he is joke, bye to him in a cloud of his own self importance. Fielding is no loss to representing Vics as very few vic cockys need a 4wd to pick up the milk.

Posted by: Russell Jones, Toowomba

Friday, 05 September 2008

"Benson playing games!" more like "Jones talking out of his rectum!". Jones - you've just changed the numbers. Your previous entry is there for ALL to see. You don't have an argument. YOU are a waste of space.

Posted by: Gareth Benson, Lane Cove

Friday, 05 September 2008

R. Jones just dropped $18,000 and is still making the same argument? Sounds a bit like Wayne Swan ... "downward pressure on interest rates and inflation"... "10 interest rises in a row" "boring, boring, boring!"

Posted by: Geoffrey Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Friday, 05 September 2008

Mandate? What Mandate? He wasnt in on the back of a landslide, he won on the back of a RORT called "preference" votes. Krudd is roughly reliant on the good will of 7 seats . So for you Lib haters waiting watching, keep your eye on the ball yeah, cause some other parties may just show enough GOOD sense to block along with the LIBS.

Posted by: Nick Again, Maryborough

 

Friday, 05 September 2008

The farmers are not the target as most of them are on welfare anyway. Any way you cut it, it's a whole bunch of cynical new taxes just to make Rudd & Swan look good.

Posted by: A Narchy, The Hills

 

Friday, 05 September 2008

WHo cares what people need or dont? Why should we have to work our arses off to pay taxes on our wages. Then when you think you can go and buy yourself a bit of luxury, some tosser wants to up the ante on the tax. WHY? So they dont see some one from a lower class driving the same model car? Ubelievable. Try making a govt business that works and pays its way, you know, create some MORE jobs,then you will get your Damn money. Try doing something positive for once instead of negativity.

Posted by: Nick Again, Maryborough

 

Friday, 05 September 2008

Fielding is a bozzo. What on earth is he doing except trying to make himself look important. It will be interesting to see how he goes in a double dissolution election. Family first is a dumb idea for a political party, the sooner it's wiped off the map the better. Everyone who voted for him hang your heads in shame.

Posted by: Graeme Henderson, Darling Downs

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
LiveNews now available on mobile devices

YOUR SAY

Yeah, Simone will be a great asset to the poms too... and not too far too far for a holiday in Spain. Perhaps we could... Once Was Proud, NSW on Shane Warne approached to coach England

Yeah I watched it. Thought the questioning was tough but justified. There should always be tough questions asked when there are civilian casualties. Though I... Jo Stalin, Sydney on UN halts aid to Gaza over safety fears

fidel castro, london,, just how do you intend to get hamas to ''obey international law'' since they always will vow to wipe the jews out,... Major Payne, Boondocks on Shabby Sheikh trying to whip up trouble over Gaza

there is a higher law his son overturned the tables of the money lenders at the temple, later his own people crucified him---- are there... allan aitchison, frankston on Brown slams Gunns' bullyboy tactics

Bring on Warney as coach. He'll show the suits at the ECB who is boss, but that's probably why they would not hire him, they... Alex Spurge, Hampshire on Shane Warne approached to coach England