Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Saturday, 22 November 2008

'Australia's worst ever treasurer': Lib MPs savage Swan

3/09/2008 10:47:00 AM.  | Anil Lambert-Patel

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

Outspoken Liberal MPs Don Randall and Peter Dutton have launched a scathing attack on Treasurer Wayne Swan, describing him as the "worst treasurer ever" and claiming he is as bad as "the treasurer of Zimbabwe".

In what appears to be a strategic new Opposition line, both Mr Randall and Mr Dutton referred to Mr Swan as the “worst treasurer of all time”.

The MPs suggested that the RBA’s rate cut yesterday was a response to Labor running the economy down in its first 10 months of office.

“He’s one of the worst treasurers this country’s ever had,” Mr Randall told reporters outside Parliament House this morning.

“I don’t think the treasurer of Zimbabwe would be any worse to be perfectly frank with you.

“They were left with a prisitine economy when they took over from us, with a huge surplus, and they’ve gradually run it down.

“They’ve run down business confidence in Australia to the extent that the Reserve Bank’s had to kickstart it.”

Mr Dutton, the Opposition's finance spokesman, said Labor's $22 billion budget surplus should be spent on the Australian people.

The Government has promised to hold the surplus as a buffer to local and international economic challenges, whilst saving it for nation building initiatives.

But Mr Dutton says the treasurer needs to clarify his position.

“What I’m saying today is that Australia’s worst ever treasurer, Mr Swan, should come out and say what the surpluses are for,” he said.

“Are the surpluses for spending or for saving?

“Because at the moment what they’re telling us is that they’re saving these huge surpluses and they’re also going to spend them. And it doesn’t lend any economic credibility to Mr Swan whatsoever.”

Video: Jon Bullock

COMMENTS

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Randall and Dutton ? Who ? Poor men are deluded - probably from the shock of seeing an interest rate cut.

Posted by: Neil Mason, Sydney

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Mason, get your head out of the sand (or your bum!), this is the reality of where Labor are dragging us. This "cut" comes only "weeks" after the rate went up! At best you can claim that we are back where we were in July!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Oh Dear Me,How did these two idiots get Elected? Perhaps they should have a look at RBA minutes from December before they comment about the PRISTINE Economy they left in November.I know it's tough being in opposition but the way the Libs are behaving lately they are destined to occupy that position for a very long time.Please bring back Costello ASAP.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

DApto, In October RBA said "inflation was under control". Further, low unemployment, sustained growth is not a bad position to inherit. YOU, by repeating the comment above, simply re-inforces all the bad mouthing that Swan did in the early days. Convicted through your own words Dapto.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Mr Bolton:RBA figures for October are not the same as DECEMBERS! Inflation a problem and will continue to rise.Need to curb spending.Consequences: Retail sales suffer=Manufacturers suffer=Business confidence lower=Job losses= Not Swans fault=Must have been Costello's fault= I win. LOL

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Paul, after 10 months in the job you are still claiming the screwing up of the economy as someone else's fault, not Swan's. So when are your beloved irrelevant, irresponsible, incompetent labor government start taking accountability for its action (or lack of it)? Man, you guys are hopeless. It's a fact that economy has been screwed after Nov last year and everyone was worse off than last year. You simply cannot dispute that.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

WO: You of all people understand the consequences of fighting Inflation (Which was a problem before November You can't dispute that)by curbing spending with Monetary policy,Jobs get lost.It's as simple as that.You really need to be more Centered in your comments and take into account all facts and figures,NOT just the one's that suit you best.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Keating - how about why the economy slowed NOW despite currently high inflation rate? As I said before, Howard managed to keep lower inflation and a booming economy AT THE SAME TIME! So obviously Howard was doing something right which Rudd & Co are incapable of. If only by destroying the economy in order to get inflation low and interest rate low - well a monkey can also do that! Obviously this is at the same level Rudd & Co are capable of.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

yeah, john howard was such a brilliant treasurer.

Posted by: dilli gaf, sticks

 

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

when i read the headline i though this would be about costello...this sounds like something costello has written himself...what a weak individual he is.

Posted by: wayne kerrs, sydney

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Wayne Kerrs, pity the same effort you applied fooling the swear filters didn't translate to your post. Typical leftist drivel from a staunch left wing troglodyte. Perhaps the weak individual is you or perhaps you are one of Kevvy's luvvies that has trouble with comprehension such as a headline; obviously a biproduct of Krudds education revolution. Enjoy the next two years comrade, it will be your last.

Posted by: Blampa Blamping, Peoples republic of Krudd

 

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Before the last election I wrote to Wayne Swan .Rudd and Swan were carrying on about the Capacity constraints. I informed Mr. Swan that if Labor were to win the election they would solve the capacity constraints problem, very quickly, because their economic, industrial and environmental policies would cause a slowdown in the economy and that would lead to less of a demand for Labour and bingo-problem solved. It is happening just as predicted and in Labors own budget there is an admission that unemployment will hit 4.75%. The way things are going that figure could be a lot higher. It is because of the slow down that the RBA has started hitting the panic button to reduce interest rates even though inflation is running at 4.5% and is expected to hit 5%.During the tenure of the last Coalition Government interest rates did go up but they went up in a setting of tremendous job growth-unemployment rate down from (Labors) 8.2% TO 4.5%.Labor has a history of putting this sort of pressure on the

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

cont....Reserve Bank. In 1990 the interest rate was 17.5 and then panic set in and the interest rate fell to 7.5% by 1992 but this rapid decrease was still not enough to save us from Keating’s recession. So the rate during the recession was 7.5%. When John Howard left office, handing over a strong economy, the rate was 6.75%.And just as we are getting the Rudd spin now Keating tried to spin his way out of the recession by claiming that the recession was just another lever of economic management.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

If body language is anything to go by then it looks like Wayne Swann is struggling to cope in his role of Treasurer. It is written all over his face that he's taken on more than he can handle. That's what is so worrying, and maybe it's that which attracted the uncomplimentary remarks by Messrs Randall and Dutton.

Posted by: Pat of Perth, Huntingdale

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

Spot on, he seems to be a decent bloke but he doesn't seem to be a decent Treasurer.

Posted by: Rob Banks, Canberra

 

Wednesday, 03 September 2008

If anyone watched 7:30 report this mob called Swan is a really thick skinned animal. He claims credit RBA raised interest rate to curb inflation! Can he claim credit for RBA's action? When grilled by the host about why the economy slowed, he said that 12 interest rate rises over the years caused big impact. But he has nothing to say other than rhetoric rubbish when the host pointed out that 8 of the 12 occurs before Nov 2006. So the majority of rises occurs almost at least 2 years ago.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
Register to receive daily news and sports details

YOUR SAY

Releasing 1 cover album does not equate to going down the Human Nature route.They are on their 5th.As others have mentioned Guy Sebastian had some... Sammy B, Adelaide on The 'Australian Idol' journey: a guaranteed road to ruin

Have some compassion some of you - my heart goes out to all close to this family. Perhaps those condemning the father should get... Julie Whale, Melbourne on Police try to piece together Tathra drowning tragedy

Ponting should have been sacked when he lost the Ashes. In fact he should never have been captain of the Australian team, Ricky... ricky punter, Adelaide on Kiwis on eve of dream Test win

Jesse, your article was an accurate exposition of the appalling non-event that is (and hopefully was - BB is gone and I live in hope)... darren carrow, brisbane on The 'Australian Idol' journey: a guaranteed road to ruin

Obviously John you believe the cry of suicide without the end result of death, isn't something to be taken seriously. Sadly you would be very... susan lawe, wherever on Teen commits suicide for internet audience