Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Saturday, 10 January 2009

Swan defends budget deficit prediction

27/11/2008 11:28:00 AM.  | AAP
Federal Treasurer Wayne Swan has defended the government's new-found liking for a budget deficit, saying doing otherwise is irresponsible.

The government admitted, for the first time, on Wednesday that it was willing to let its budget fall into deficit to stave off the effects of the global financial crisis.

Mr Swan said a deficit was necessary "right now" because the government continued to project modest growth and modest surpluses.

"But it would be irresponsible to rule it out," he told ABC Radio.

All the risks for the economy were on the downside, and that will have an impact on revenue and employment.

The government would be looking for savings during its budget process next year, Mr Swan said.

However, Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull says Labor governments can't say no when it comes to spending.

Ultimately, they run up a lot of debt and get into trouble, he said.

"If all the government does is spend, spend, spend, if it doesn't say no to anybody or anything, ultimately you run up a lot of debt and that's where Labor governments have historically gotten themselves into a lot of difficulties," Mr Turnbull told Fairfax Radio Network.

Economic management needed discipline and judgment from which the government was seeking a leave pass by allowing the budget to go into deficit, he said.

COMMENTS

Thursday, 27 November 2008

I dont think anyone would deny that a deficit may be necessary but we are fed up to the back teeth with all the political point scoring that Swan and Rudd are putting on. The story changes from week to week to suit Rudd political aganda. Like NSW he is putting politics ahead of the nation. It is a common Labor ploy - as long as they keep power they dont really care about the damage they cause along the way. Just look at NSW.

Posted by: Pete 2, North Sydney

 

Thursday, 27 November 2008

How can anybody belive this dead duck! - only a couple of months ago the ringmaster Rudd and his chief clown Swan told us Australia would only suffer minor impacts from GFC. With all the brilliant minds in Treasury, Reserve Bank etc, why have the current Govt. allowed us to slid into such a mess?

Posted by: Lee Willi, Brisbane

Thursday, 27 November 2008

Minor impact and better able to ride this crisis out than any other country. We also have a buffer to protect us, $23bil surplus...It WILL have a 2 in front of it... All spin from Rudd and Swan... Now because other major economies, in far worse position than we were, UK, Japan etc, have gone nto deficit this Govt thinks they can take us into deficit along with them. Our rates are 5.25 compared to the UK 3 ,Japan 0.3, other countries in deficit have lower rates too..The handouts given by Rudd have yet to be figured in, just 2 examples of possible stumuli yet to come, a rate cut and the billions in handouts...why not wait until we see how these will effect the economy before we rush to approve going into deficit. I agree with Hockey, he has't even given us a plan on what the "deficit" would be spent on. Maybe Hockey is right, they have no economic plan, only politics.

Posted by: susan lawe, wherever

Thursday, 27 November 2008

Susan Lawe:You obviously watched Hockey on Tv last night as you have plagiarized his comments.However you neglect to say Hockey was put right on Rates! The RBA sets the rates not the Government.Now as far as Hockey's comments about waiting to see how the Handouts will or will not effect our economy.How long do we wait? Whats the trigger point for more action? When our heads are under water and Unemployment is sky high.Is that the Libs Policy??? Give me a Proactive Government Any Day.

Posted by: Paul Keating, Dapto

 

Thursday, 27 November 2008

That's true Willi. It was only a few months ago when Rudd urged Australians to stay calm over the financial cricis. He used the surplus as one of the advantages we have over other countries, to convince us that there was no need to panic saying that Australia's in good position. Look at the situation now!

Posted by: Aurora Australis, Melbourne, http://aurora-australis.proboards.com

 

Thursday, 27 November 2008

At the time of the last election some of the pundits were telling us that people would vote for Labor because they were feeling quite comfortable about the economy-meaning they didn't mind handing over the economy to the inexperienced team of Rudd and Swan because it was going so well. One wonders if the pundits and those people are feeling very comfortable right now.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Wednesday, 03 December 2008

Desmond Harris ran the Liberal Party line: "handing over the economy to the inexperienced team of Rudd and Swan" What was the experience of Howard and Costello before they came into government? Costello? Ec. experience: zero. Basher of workers unions. Howard's experience was Treasurer 1975-83. He brought us the worst recession since the Great Depression. The only Treasurer in history to engineer, simultaneously: double-digit inflation double-digit unemployment double-digit interest rates

Posted by: Ellar Starr, Votersville

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
LiveNews now available on mobile devices

YOUR SAY

What gives you the riught to oppress poor Tinitin? Just beacuse he is "only" a cartoon character? Cartoon characters are deserving of our... Mick S, Central Coast on Is Tintin gay? Cartoon birthday boy dogged by rumours

Actually, the use of the word "probably" isn't a proclamation of agnosticism, but rather an atheist's way of saying that we aren't so bold as... j gates, fairlight on Australian atheists banned from bus blitz

Harry, realistically, Hamas needs to rescind its vow to "destroy" Israel? No one is going to revert to a weaker position just to aid the... Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove on Israel presses on with Gaza strikes despite UN resolution

An actor with mental issues. Since when is that breaking news!... Pithy Opiner, Stockton, California on French actor detained over Paris bar stabbing

Regadless of the fact that they where cross breeds and NOT Pure bred Bull Mastiffs......the reporter should get the facts straight.........what person in their right... Jenny Bestdogs, Cornwall on Bullmastiffs must be banned